Let the people own their data

Print Article

Great responsibilities should come with great power and profits.

WHEN FACEBOOK CEO Mark Zuckerberg sat before the House Financial Services Committee last week he must have felt like the turkey who gets invited over for Thanksgiving dinner.

The supposed reason for Zuckerberg being there was to face questions over Facebook's plan to - seriously - create its own digital currency. Congressional Democrats and Republicans have expressed concerns because, well, usually creating currency is something sovereign nations do.

Beyond that rather important point, committee members had plenty of other questions ranging from Facebook's troubling record on issues related to privacy, misinformation, hate speech, racist speech and other civil rights matters.

IN FAIRNESS, Zuckerberg and his company are just one prominent example of a massive problem involving society's relationship to digital media. It's fair to say Silicon Valley has vastly outpaced the law's ability to keep up with the so-called information age.

Part of that is by design. This is still a fairly new industry, and it was smart to avoid burdening it early on with choking regulatory boundaries. But as digital companies have matured the scope of mistakes - and deliberate misbehavior - has become more obvious.

In the wild west digital climate it was easy for bad foreign actors to attack U.S. elections with effective disinformation campaigns. It has been relatively easy for hackers to steal personal data. Worse, digital companies profit enormously by collecting and selling the personal information of millions of people. Copyrighted content routinely is lifted without compensating producers. And the largest digital companies mostly deny responsibility for objectionable, even false, content carried on those platforms.

The companies routinely argue they can police themselves. Evidence suggests that's "fake news."

QUESTION: WHO OWNS the personal data you create by using digital media?

Hint: It's not you.

Question: The last time you were on a digital site and were asked to accept its terms of use, did you read it?

Hint: Neither does anybody else. It's too dense. Too hard to understand. And that's not by accident.

We believe a fundamental congressional responsibility is to protect the people from being preyed upon, both from bad actors bent on harm and from companies intent on profiteering by invading privacy. We believe one should own their personal data. We believe companies should have to get permission - through brief, easy-to-understand terms that must be regularly renewed - before mining data for profit. We believe there should be consequences for abusive practices. We believe people should be able to withdraw consent at any time, quickly and easily.

The digital age holds enormous promise - and equally enormous threat. Congress needs to be a better referee.

Print Article

Read More Editorials

Better options for legal costs?

December 02, 2019 at 10:30 am | School district's trendline for legal fees is alarming. A QUICK LOOK on the Google machine finds multiple sources providing figures for how much lawyers in Wisconsin get paid annually. Undoubtedly...


Read More

At least both sides like trips

December 02, 2019 at 10:29 am | No doubt, citizens will benefit immensely from political tourism. WHO SAYS ELECTED members of the Wisconsin legislature can't get anything done? And who says they can't do anything in a bipartisa...


Read More

The proper forum is at the Capitol

November 25, 2019 at 9:19 am | WHAT IS KNOWN as "conversion therapy" is a highly controversial practice supposedly intended to change an individual's orientation, for example, changing someone from homosexual to heterosexual. Pro...


Read More

Avoid problems, embrace the law

November 25, 2019 at 9:20 am | SOMETIMES THIS SORT of thing is called an unforced error, or even a self-inflicted wound. We refer to mistakes made by the School District of Beloit for not observing - let alone failing to welcome ...


Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2019 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy