Tide given nod over Buckeyes

Print Article

Back in January 2012, the day after Alabama beat LSU in the BCS championship game, the commissioners of the FBS conferences gathered in New Orleans to discuss the future of the college football postseason.

There had already been movement toward tearing up the unpopular Bowl Championship Series, but the all-Southeastern Conference championship game was the final blow. The College Football Playoff was created soon after.

On Sunday, the field for the fourth College Football Playoff was set and for the first time two teams from the same conference made it. Alabama (11-1) will face Clemson (12-1) in the Sugar Bowl and fellow SEC member Georgia (12-1) will play Oklahoma (12-1) in the Rose Bowl.

Another all-SEC championship game could be on the horizon, and for the second straight year the value of a conference championship was diminished. Unlike in 2012, though, the winds of change are not picking up - even with both the Big Ten and Pac-12 sitting out this playoff altogether.

"It doesn't change my view that the present structure is best for college football," Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany said during an interview with ESPN. "I can be supportive of (the selection committee) and at the same time be disappointed and a little bit surprised."

When Alabama got the nod for the fourth and final spot over Ohio State, the Big Ten was left out for the first time - and for the second time in four seasons the Pac-12 was shut out, too. When the conference commissioners were putting the playoff together, ensuring only conference champions would be included was considered. Eventually, the compromise was to craft a protocol that emphasized conference championships, but not make them mandatory.

"I don't see anything that's happened in the first four years in the work of the selection committee or the playoff that is inconsistent with how it was designed or what was possible," Pac-12 Commissioner Larry Scott told the AP in a phone interview.

Tide or Buckeyes was the toughest call for the committee in the four-year history of the playoff.

The Tide had been more consistent and lost just once. The Buckeyes lost twice, including an embarrassing 31-point loss at unranked Iowa, but have the more impressive set of victories. Ohio State won the Big Ten while Alabama did not even win its SEC division.

The committee rolled with the Tide and stayed on the task of choosing the best teams, regardless of conference affiliation. For the second straight season a team that did not win its conference is in the playoff. Ohio State did it last year.

"Of course we all know at the end of the day what the narrative is going to be based on the identification of the those four very best teams because we're all in this profession. This is our livelihood. We're very familiar with it," Hocutt said. "But does it impact our discussion in that room? And I can tell you very straight forward no."

Ohio State was ranked fifth by the CFP, Wisconsin was sixth and Auburn was seventh. Southern California finished eighth, followed by Penn State and Miami. Washington was 11th and unbeaten UCF was 12th.

The rest of the New Year's Six bowls fell this way: USC (11-2) vs. Ohio State (11-2) in the Cotton Bowl on Dec. 29 ; Washington (10-2) vs. Penn State (10-2) in the Fiesta Bowl on Dec. 30 ; Miami (10-2) vs. Wisconsin (12-1) in the Orange Bowl on Dec. 30 ; and UCF (12-0) vs. Auburn (10-3) in the Peach Bowl on Jan. 1 .

"Look at how healthy the system is," Scott said. "From our perspective, of course we'd love a team in the playoff this year, but we've got amazing bowl games."

Hocutt said the Iowa loss hurt Ohio State and the Buckeyes were not close enough to the Tide for the Big Ten championship result - a 27-21 win over previously unbeaten Wisconsin - to matter.

Alabama made it 4-for-4 in the playoff, the only team that has made them all. Coach Nick Saban said he trusted the committee would come to the right conclusion.

Print Article

Read More Sports News

Giannis hurt as Bucks fall

March 22, 2018 at 10:02 am | MILWAUKEE (AP) - Their playoff hopes fading after a deflating loss a night earlier, the Los Angeles Clippers were desperate for a win. "We've got to be one team, one unit and play with high energy a...


Read More

Aggies glad star forward stuck around

March 22, 2018 at 10:02 am | LOS ANGELES (AP) - Robert Williams is a living, breathing, windmill-dunking advertisement for the upside of staying in school. The Texas A&M big man with the 7-foot-5 wingspan clearly had all th...


Read More

Cain, Yelich give Brewers boost

March 22, 2018 at 10:02 am | MILWAUKEE (AP) - The Milwaukee Brewers' pitching could improve this year better because of two new bats in the lineup: Outfielders Lorenzo Cain and Christian Yelich are just as capable of changing ga...


Read More

Hungry Cubs looking for fast start this season

March 22, 2018 at 10:04 am | CHICAGO (AP) - The Chicago Cubs remember what it was like in 2016, and they remember what happened last year. They remember all the fun they had two years ago, and how tired they were at the end of l...


Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2018 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy