EDITORIAL: Open window to an ugly world - Beloit Daily News: Opinion

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

EDITORIAL: Open window to an ugly world

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, February 27, 2013 4:00 pm

If the choice is between partisan ambition and democracy, democracy loses every time.


THERE MAY BE SOME element of suspense for lawyers as the courts continue to grapple with issues related to Wisconsin’s redistricting process, but most people have known for months what the politicians are loathe to admit.

Yes, majority Republicans manipulated a constitutionally required task, drawing district boundary lines purely to benefit their party and disadvantage Democrats. They did it because they could. And they did it with purpose, intending to lock in control of government at least until the next census, in 2020.

They just don’t want to publicly acknowledge rigging the electoral game, because that reveals politicians do all in their power to pick their voters rather than allow voters to pick their representatives. While they may eagerly embrace such an anti-democratic opportunity, they’ll scrap to the death trying not to get caught holding the smoking gun that proves such duplicity.


A THREE-JUDGE FEDERAL PANEL hearing the case, though, isn’t going along. And before the zealots start shouting about activist liberal judges, note the composition of the panel: One judge appointed by Ronald Reagan, one by George W. Bush, one by Bill Clinton.

At issue is whether those controlling the legislature turned over all pertinent information. The court has locked horns with the majority throughout the case, at one point levying a $17,500 fine against their attorneys for frivolously filing motions trying to withhold documents. At another juncture the court pried loose more records which had been withheld in spite of disclosure orders.

For months plaintiffs have been seeking access to three government computers used to draw maps, to search for other material wrongly withheld. The majority has fiercely resisted. This week the judges, clearly frustrated, lost patience and ordered the computers be turned over immediately for forensic review.

“The computers are extremely likely to contain relevant and responsive materials that should have been disclosed during pretrial discovery,” the court’s opinion stated. “Moreover, plaintiffs have established that substantial numbers of documents were not disclosed, which satisfies the court that some form of fraud, misrepresentation or misconduct likely occurred.”


STRONG WORDS. And rightly so, since so much hangs in the balance. In the first place, disciplinary actions against the legislature’s lawyers — and possibly others — could follow if they are found to have violated court procedures and directives intentionally.

More importantly for voters, if egregious violations are discovered the redistricting case could be reopened. Initially, the judges upheld most of the remap outcome — only two districts in the Milwaukee area were changed — although the ruling chided legislators for pursuing an overtly partisan strategy.

So the stakes are high, which certainly raises suspicions about the bulldog-like determination with which legislative leaders have resisted full disclosure.

Legal proceedings are about as exciting as watching a cow chew grass, but this one has opened a fascinating window into a world voters seldom get to see — a world where all the rhetorical jibber-jabber is silenced, and the full nature of the partisan power-grab is on display as democracy is sacrificed to ambition and control.


A FINAL WORD: The outcome of this case is unlikely to alter the balance of power in Wisconsin. Don’t expect manipulated lines to be un-manipulated. The real value of this case — pulling the curtain back on the sausage-making — is to alert voters to the pressing need for redistricting reform. It doesn’t have to be this bad. Some other states — Iowa is a good example — have scored significant successes in taking partisan interests out of the remap process, preserving choices for voters. Wisconsin could, too. Here’s the truth: Partisan politicians cannot be trusted to serve the interest of democracy; they will serve their own interests, instead, if they can. In Wisconsin, it was the Republicans. In Illinois, it’s the Democrats. In each instance, the people lost. This partisan system is corrupt — as the court said, prone to “fraud, misrepresentation and misconduct.” Any politician who opposes change goes against the people, and deserves to be fired at the next election.

  • Discuss

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
  • 2 Don't Threaten or Abuse. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated. AND PLEASE TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
  • 3 Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
  • 4 Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 5 Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 6 Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Welcome to the discussion.


  • Mr Data posted at 12:02 pm on Mon, Mar 4, 2013.

    Mr Data Posts: 4179

    It's irrational radivcal right winged thinking like that 1badbubyu that ensures the liberal view will ALWAYS rule.

    It's time for everyone to strive to move towards the center of the political universe.

  • 1badbubyu posted at 8:16 am on Mon, Mar 4, 2013.

    1badbubyu Posts: 1497

    Oooooooor...if one day the conservative thinker outnumbers the "moderate" republican and we just take the party.

    that would be cool....[lol]

  • Blah-de-Blah posted at 1:12 pm on Sun, Mar 3, 2013.

    Blah-de-Blah Posts: 140

    Amen Data. The day where a politician takes fault for something that is going on is the day that I will stand behind him, or her, and support them. Why? Because that politician will be a greater man, or woman, than any other politician on capitol hill.

  • Mr Data posted at 5:38 pm on Sat, Mar 2, 2013.

    Mr Data Posts: 4179

    BRAVO billtinder for starting to see the errors of political bias and their stupid party allegiance - democrat or republican.

    Independent is wise and is the most FAIR and BALANCED political view one can take.

    When flying independently you'll soon see the truel ignorance pandered daily to us by those in BOTH political parties. It's really sickening and is hard to understand how people's minds (especially the 'so-called' more learned people) have become so warped and poisoned with their political venom.

    When someone at any level -- but especially those at our national leadership levels (like the Prez, the HoR Speaker, the US Senate Majority Leader, etc.) -- continually claim it is not they who are "responsible" for 'anything' questionable that happens in our nation a truly wise eprson has to ask .. then what the heck are they really doing in their jobs? Sounds like nothing! They're being very deceitful if they expect us to believe their B.S. We know no one is perfect all of the time. Especially not these scoundrels!

  • billtinder posted at 6:05 pm on Fri, Mar 1, 2013.

    billtinder Posts: 4887

    I totally agree with both of you and that is why I also call myself a conservative leaning independent.

  • 1badbubyu posted at 1:37 pm on Thu, Feb 28, 2013.

    1badbubyu Posts: 1497

    I am truly ashamed of Wi. Republicans when it comes to the redistricting issue. I don't feel rotten politics such as this are needed to make the more conservative approach popular. Other states have proved it. This is clearly a huge black eye on the face of Wi. Repubs. This is also exactly why I consider myself an independent conservative and not a party line Republican. I'm in total favor of reviewing and overhauling the redistricting rules. We need these tactics outlawed for both parties.

  • Blah-de-Blah posted at 11:09 pm on Wed, Feb 27, 2013.

    Blah-de-Blah Posts: 140


    Democracy isn't just losing in America, it's being slaughtered by its own government. Why? Our government has become so unpopular that now its leaders fear rebuttal by the people they control. So what's the only way that they can control them? Simple: manipulate them into believing a huge lie, and then let them demand for the action that they want. Perfectly executed, and it's still working. Well, at least on those who haven't looked behind the screen to see what is truly there.


Print ads