Bipartisanship! (for self-interest)

Print Article

Dear politicians: The people may not be as stupid as you think.

AND THE DOUBLE STANDARD continues in the political world, this time in Madison.

Just hours before NBC announced it had fired popular Today show host Matt Lauer, the top Republican and the top Democrat in the Wisconsin Assembly - Republican Speaker Robin Vos and Democrat Minority Leader Gordon Hintz - stood shoulder-to-shoulder to announce they would not release any information on behavioral investigations involving Assembly legislators or their staffers. The Wisconsin State Journal and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel have been seeking such documents under the Public Records Law. Legislative leaders have denied document requests - including in the case of former Republican Assembly Majority Leader Bill Kramer, who was convicted in 2014 for fourth-degree sexual assault.

The politicians' reasoning? They say they want to protect victims and that public release of information about investigations might discourage other victims from coming forward.

THERE THEY GO AGAIN, assuming the folks out here in the real world are too stupid to see through that batch of horse hockey.

In the first place, the only victimization secrecy might prevent is how the voters might victimize politicians or top staff accused of bad behavior if the information got out.

Secondly, plenty of victims may want the stories told because doing so would discourage abusers from thinking they could get away with it in the future.

Finally, consider: Would a victim be more likely to come forward if they knew their story would be taken seriously and openly, or if they believe the powerful person they felt mistreated them could keep it all hush-hush with the support of the rest of the legislature?

Likewise, we find this interesting. Republicans and Democrats in Madison couldn't agree the sun rises in the east each morning, but they can get into lockstep over keeping bad behavior secret.

IN REPORTING BY the Journal Sentinel, Jennifer Drobac - a law professor at Indiana University and author of a law school textbook on sexual harassment - said secrecy "put more women at risk" from powerful men. "It makes women vulnerable when we keep these histories secret," she said. "Sunlight is still the best disinfectant."

Keep in mind, Speaker Vos - along with Gov. Scott Walker and Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald - was behind the sneaky attempt to gut Wisconsin's Public Records Law over the July Fourth weekend a couple years ago.

Keep in mind, too, that Minority Leader Hintz in 2011 was swept up as part of a prostitution sting at an Appleton massage parlor.

The secrecy ploy is so clearly self-serving the so-called reasons can't be taken seriously. The public interest in knowing when powerful legislators or their staffers are accused of acting abusively is starkly obvious. When there are legitimate privacy interests, the law recognizes redaction - blacking out victims' names - as the proper way to address the situation. For that matter, it is common media practice to protect the identities of sexual abuse victims unless individuals choose to go on the record.

Thus, there can be no other conclusion: This is a bipartisan cover-your-butt operation.

Print Article

Read More Editorials

About outcomes, and measuring

October 09, 2018 at 10:15 am | Leadership shift creates an opportunity for deep change, but it's later than we think. ANOTHER YEAR, another round of state academic test results and the conclusion remains: The School District of...


Read More

Preparing youth for adult culture

October 01, 2018 at 10:12 am | It can be jolting when young people discover the demands of the workplace. ORLANDO RAMOS, the new principal at Beloit Memorial High School, said it well: "Kids are brutally honest, and they don't ...


Read More

He knows better, repeats it anyway

October 01, 2018 at 10:12 am | Anyone can flub a number. But, eventually, repeating an error looks like something else. HE DID IT AGAIN. It's one thing to mangle a fact. It's another thing to mangle it again and again even thou...


Read More

Promises, promises during election 2018

September 24, 2018 at 10:44 am | Keep a skeptical ear as politicians up the rhetorical ante in close races. IN WISCONSIN and across the nation this is an election year, so brace yourself for outlandish promises delivered with str...


Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2018 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy