Guest Commentary Democrats should stop attacking school choice

Print Article

MILWAUKEE - Imagine this scenario: A candidate for governor threatens to completely eliminate the food stamp program, sending thousands of Milwaukee families scrambling to replace a fundamental human need. Our fellow Democrats would be aghast. After all, food assistance provides families in need with the ability and dignity to make nutritional choices for themselves.

But as statements by the current Democratic gubernatorial candidates show, similar attacks on another social benefit - Wisconsin's school choice program - are widely accepted and even embraced as "progressive."

ANTI-school choice views seemingly dominate the Democratic Party of Wisconsin. To a casual observer, the once muscular pro-school choice wing of the party (think former Milwaukee Mayor John Norquist and the late Assemblywoman Polly Williams) appears to have been vanquished.

But recent data shows this is not the case. According to a poll commissioned by the Wisconsin Institute of Law and Liberty, 46 percent of our state's Democratic voters support the idea of educational savings accounts that would "allow parents to receive a portion of the money that would have been spent on their children in a public school." Also, more than a quarter of Democratic voters support "vouchers" and over one-third support charter schools.

While these numbers are not majorities, the data reveals Democrats don't hold monolithic views on education. In short, among Democratic voters, the intraparty debate continues over providing tools of educational empowerment directly to families.

FINANCIALLY well-off whites, such as Democratic candidates for governor Matt Flynn and Kelda Roys, have always been able to exercise their own school choice. After all, paying out of pocket for a private school or moving into an affluent public school district is an exercise in choice. It is also a reflection of inequitable privilege, the breaking down of which is voiced by many of the same activists who so stridently attack Wisconsin's school choice programs.

The causes of the candidates' views are hardly a mystery. A significant portion of the Democratic Party's activist class is personally invested in district schools as teachers and public school union members. Unlike the teachers' unions, black and brown families in Milwaukee, Racine and Green Bay seldom have the resources to competitively lobby their own interests.

THE Democratic Party champions social justice issues and fights for the marginalized. So instead of being a mere megaphone for teachers' unions, the Democratic Party should be advancing the interests of all students and parents, regardless of the educational option they choose.

We can unify families by calling for every type of school to be better supported by our state government. The focus should be to improve the scholarly and extracurricular success of every young person in Wisconsin.

Wisconsin Democrats should stop the constant ad hominem attacks on choice and charter schools. After all, more than 30,000 Milwaukee school children attend choice and charter schools. Overwhelmingly, these children are from low-income black and brown families. These families have made a choice about their child's future and they deserve to have that decision respected.

DEMOCRATIC Party leaders' embrace of the school sector war that treats children as market share must end. Beat the political swords into ploughshares and focus on better funding, accountability using apples-to-apples testing, and real consequences for schools that fail to achieve academic success. An articulated goal of better educational outcomes across sectors would resonate with Wisconsin voters and be a boon to Democrats' long-term political and social objectives.

Politics is the game of addition. By continuing to advocate for the destruction of school choice and charter programs, the Democratic Party leadership continues to subtract from its membership those who want to empower families to make their own educational choices. It's time to recognize the futility of this position and return a respected, vocal, pro-educational choice wing to the party.

This article was published first in the Wisconsin State Journal. Sherwin Hughes is the host of "The Forum" weekdays from 9 a.m. to noon on WNOV-AM (860) and W293CX-FM (106.5) in Milwaukee: Dan Adams is a criminal defense attorney in Milwaukee: Dan Adams is a Beloit memorial High School graduate and the son of Jeff and Judy Adams of Beloit.

Print Article

Read More Columnists

Firm won't get tax-break vote by Sept. 30

September 17, 2018 at 10:24 am | THERE are several reasons why Republican Gov. Scott Walker and lawmakers won't meet Kimberly-Clark's ultimatum to approve Foxconn-like tax breaks by Sept. 30. "We've requested that the vote occur by...


Read More

Fights over assessments, property tax loom

September 11, 2018 at 12:01 pm | Manawa in Waupaca County boasts this motto: "Celebrating small town life." But, in the looming Capitol brawls over how property is assessed and whether the property tax is a sustainable way to pay f...


Read More

WALTERS: Catching up on summer news run

September 04, 2018 at 12:12 pm | It was another much-too-busy summer. Your days off were too packed to make time for news. The kids are heading back to school. This is your annual "summer's over, what did I miss" column? Q. Is it...


Read More

America overdue for Lehman-like episode

August 21, 2018 at 10:13 am | WASHINGTON -- Eric Sevareid (1912-1992), the author and broadcaster, said he was a pessimist about tomorrow but an optimist about the day after tomorrow. Regarding America's economy, prudent people s...


Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2018 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy