Your Right to Know Can courts exempt themselves from the law?

Print Article

A few weeks back, while looking into a court case in Waukesha County, I went to the court's website seeking contact information. There were a few phone numbers but no email addresses. So I called one of the numbers and asked for the judge's email address.

The judge's office wouldn't give it to me.

GIVEN that judges and other court employees use a government email address, I decided to file an open records request, seeking the email addresses of everyone who uses the domain address, which is administered by the court system.

The response I received from Randy Koschnick, the director of state courts, was chilling: "The Wisconsin Supreme Court intends to decide whether the state court system is subject to the open records law," he informed me. "The issue is currently under consideration by the Court."

This was certainly news to me. In response to my follow-up query, Koschnick said there was no pending case regarding this matter, but that the issue has risen recently "so the court has determined that it is appropriate for the court to address it."

NO ONE I contacted seemed to be aware that the state's highest court was, on its own initiative, deciding if it could essentially exempt itself from state law, much as the Wisconsin state Legislature tried to do in 2015. That effort was abandoned after a huge public outcry.

The state's open records law explicitly lists "any court of law" as among the entities that are subject to its provisions. The only way the courts could decide they weren't covered, it seems, would be through a separation of powers argument - essentially, that the state Legislature has no authority to tell the courts what to do.

If that's the case, the courts could theoretically exempt themselves from any other law.

MY efforts to seek clarification and my request to speak to Chief Justice Patience Roggensack have been ignored. But another court official, spokesman Tom Sheehan, was quoted as saying the court is only considering whether the email addresses have to be released. He cited a "substantial risk" of litigants improperly communicating with judges, which could lead to the need for judges to disqualify themselves.

The email issue is a red herring. If an email is on an inappropriate topic, it can be ignored the same as the judge can ignore any other communication. Obviously, some court officials would prefer to remain inaccessible. Probably so would a lot of mayors and state lawmakers. But this is Wisconsin, where we supposedly believe in open government.

SOME judges routinely use their emails, and in most cases their email addresses are easy to figure out. In Waukesha County, all you have to do is put a period between the first and last name and add @ and voila! If the court really felt that access to email addresses is a threat to justice, why hasn't it banned judges from making their email addresses public?

For the state's highest court to exempt itself from the state law on access to records would be an abusive power grab. If that's what's being considered, Roggensack and the other justices first need to explain themselves.

Your Right to Know is a monthly column distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council (, a group dedicated to open government. Mark Belling is a radio talk-show host in Milwaukee.

Print Article

Read More Columnists

Firm won't get tax-break vote by Sept. 30

September 17, 2018 at 10:24 am | THERE are several reasons why Republican Gov. Scott Walker and lawmakers won't meet Kimberly-Clark's ultimatum to approve Foxconn-like tax breaks by Sept. 30. "We've requested that the vote occur by...


Read More

Fights over assessments, property tax loom

September 11, 2018 at 12:01 pm | Manawa in Waupaca County boasts this motto: "Celebrating small town life." But, in the looming Capitol brawls over how property is assessed and whether the property tax is a sustainable way to pay f...


Read More

WALTERS: Catching up on summer news run

September 04, 2018 at 12:12 pm | It was another much-too-busy summer. Your days off were too packed to make time for news. The kids are heading back to school. This is your annual "summer's over, what did I miss" column? Q. Is it...


Read More

America overdue for Lehman-like episode

August 21, 2018 at 10:13 am | WASHINGTON -- Eric Sevareid (1912-1992), the author and broadcaster, said he was a pessimist about tomorrow but an optimist about the day after tomorrow. Regarding America's economy, prudent people s...


Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2018 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy