‘Justices vote the party line’

Print Article

No surprise, Mr. Barth wrote an editorial criticizing the recent decision by a Dane County judge to declare Act 10 null and void. As soon as I heard about the ruling I knew people would say it was just another activist judge exceeding his authority. Why is it okay for right-leaning judges to strike down liberal legislation but it is not okay for liberal judges to strike down conservative legislation?

Mr. Barth usually champions the First Amendment but in this editorial mocks the argument that it has been infringed upon. He said the judge ruled the law violates employees’ rights of free speech and association and violates the equal protection clause by creating separate classes of employees. Love or hate the law, it did do those things. Mr. Barth justifies that by saying the law was passed by duly elected representatives of the people and the recall election showed it had public support. That does not make it constitutional. How many times have the courts overturned legislation passed by elected legislatures and supported by the people in this nation’s history?

Mr. Barth wrote that for years the liberal strategy has been to go shopping for a judge when they can’t win a political victory. I think both sides are guilty of that.

Mr. Barth would like opponents of Act 10 to just give up. Would the other side just give up if the situation were reversed?

Mr. Barth is right that the state Supreme Court, the same court he himself has criticized many times, will no doubt overturn this decision because they have proven incapable of judging cases on their merits and instead vote the party line. Maybe somehow a federal issue will allow the U.S. Supreme Court to have a shot at Act 10. I trust them more than our court. 

Mike Hoey

Delavan

Print Article

Read More Opinion

Needed: Better way to pay public costs

October 20, 2017 at 4:00 pm | Relying on Madison politicians and property taxes is a failing system. IT'S THAT TIME OF YEAR, when local governments build and finalize their budgets. The newspaper has published several stories ...

Comments

Read More

'No gain' for rich? Don't believe that.

October 18, 2017 at 4:00 pm | Tax reform is a worthy goal, but details and benefits matter. IN BELOIT THIS WEEK Congressman Mark Pocan, the Madison Democrat who represents this area in the nation's capital, called proposed tax...

Comments

Read More

'The greatest threat to US is nationalism'

October 18, 2017 at 4:00 pm | The greatest threat America faces today is nationalism, which seeks to rule through intimidation of "others": other nations, undocumented people in America, and people seeking to enter the country. ...

Comments

Read More

Call it leadership, American-style

October 16, 2017 at 4:00 pm | Is punishing the poor a salve for bruised political egos? SIX MILLION PEOPLE. That's the estimated number of Americans whose health insurance premiums are subsidized under the Affordable Care Act,...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2017 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X