EDITORIAL: Wait. Who gets voucher help?

Print Article

The concept of letting poor kids escape bad schools seems to have changed.

LETíS SAY THIS up-front: We support vouchers. But let us add: Details matter.

The quick launch of a statewide private-school voucher program was bound to raise a few questions at the outset.

And it has.

Starting with this one: What exactly is the goal the program is supposed to meet, and who is supposed to benefit?

THOSE WHO HAVE FOLLOWED voucher debates the past couple of decades will remember Wisconsin was a pioneer under then-Gov. Tommy Thompson. The voucher experiment had a clear and important mission. It was offered in the city of Milwaukee to low-income families ó mostly minorities ó to provide options for students trapped in poor-performing inner-city public schools.

Todayís voucher plan is different. Itís statewide, with higher income eligibility. And in last weekís announcement of qualifying schools, the Department of Public Instruction noted that two-thirds of the applicants seeking the tax subsidy already were attending private schools. About 25 percent were attending public schools.

Wait a minute. Are vouchers intended to help poor kids escape bad schools? Or just to have taxpayers pick up the tab for students instead of their parents, who had been paying for their private education?

CLEARLY, THIS NEEDS to be clarified before the program drops enrollment caps in the third year. We doubt this is the outcome taxpayers anticipated.

Left unchecked, this could result in two parallel school systems operating in Wisconsin ó with taxpayers picking up the tab for both.

Print Article

Read More Opinion

Ask the question of more people

June 23, 2017 at 4:00 pm | Timing matters when citizens are being asked to raise their own taxes. GOOD AND BAD. That's how we would describe a slate of measures proposed in the Wisconsin Legislature to guide how school dist...

Comments

Read More

'What it means when we resist'

June 21, 2017 at 4:00 pm | The Resist signs that appear on lawns or are held by participants at rallies are not a call for obstructionism or interference with the operations of government. Rather, it is a call to not accept th...

Comments

Read More

'Keep provisions in ACA program'

June 21, 2017 at 4:00 pm | Urge your state's U.S. senators to preserve in the repeal and replace plan of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) provisions in the ACA that have strengthened Medicare including, Medicare beneficiaries' pr...

Comments

Read More

Too many secrets, not enough leaks

June 21, 2017 at 4:00 pm | Not always, but often 'leakers' act in the public interest. FOR PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP it must be hair-pulling maddening that everything around him seems to spring leaks faster than a rotting wood...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2017 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X