EDITORIAL: Don’t discourage options in school

Print Article

Bad marks for overzealous challenge to creative approach.


OVER DECADES, the American Civil Liberties Union has performed some remarkable services in the interest of individual liberty. The ACLU’s history is filled with moments when it has defended rights and upheld the Constitution -- often at unpopular junctions with public opinion -- extending liberty for all.

So let’s not jump on that bandwagon racing to condemn the ACLU as a meddlesome agent of anti-Americanism, bent on destroying every traditional belief of the people.

At the same time, the ACLU is as capable of overreaching as any other institution. Its most recent actions related to the School District of Beloit illustrate the point.


THE ACLU HAS ASKED the federal Education Department’s office of civil rights for an investigation into whether Beloit is in violation of Title IX by conducting single-sex classes at Robinson and McLenegan schools. The Beloit district is one of many across the country in the ACLU’s crosshairs.

The implication is that by filling some classrooms with boys and others with girls the school district is illegally discriminating and violating the rights of those youngsters.

Certainly, the district is making a distinction based on gender. And, if one changed the sentence above to read “filling some classrooms with blacks and others with whites” one would hear alarm bells going off all around.

But intent matters. So does parental involvement. And upon closer examination it’s obvious the Beloit program is an outcome-based experiment driven by positive motives.


THE IDEA BEHIND the single-sex approach is that boys and girls may have different learning patterns that could be enhanced by teaching to those strengths.

Keep in mind that this is a limited experiment, not an all-encompassing policy of the district. Also, remember that no child is forced to participate. Parents opt-in for the program.

Additionally, kids are not separated by gender across-the-board during the educational experience. It applies for certain core subjects. Otherwise, boys and girls mix at other times -- for lunch, for phy-ed, for other projects and class work.

So, obviously, there is no intent to deny anyone’s rights or reduce anyone’s opportunities. Quite the opposite, in fact.

More importantly, in our view, parents get to choose. Shall we accuse mom and dad of discriminating against their kid?


ON THIS ONE, it’s obvious the ACLU is way off base. Beloit must endure the distraction of defending itself for no good reason.

Likewise, for the nearly 500 other schools nationwide targeted under this ACLU request. It’s not as if Beloit invented the single-sex approach. This is common as the education community looks for ways to improve outcomes.

Call us crazy, but we believe experimentation is crucial in modern education. Why? Because the status quo isn’t enough. Too many kids are falling through the cracks. Too many are unable to function and prosper once they leave school. That’s both an individual tragedy, for kids who fail, and a national tragedy as America strives to compete and win on a global scale.

The feds should punt this one back. Beloit’s kids are not being harmed.

Print Article

Read More Opinion

'Loudenbeck shows true leadership'

June 26, 2017 at 4:00 pm | The Wisconsin Health Care Association and Wisconsin Center for Assisted Living (WHCA/WiCAL) represents skilled nursing and assisted living centers across the state. On behalf of Wisconsin's care prov...


Read More

Rule by politicians, or rule by people?

June 26, 2017 at 4:00 pm | It's not overstatement to say fate of democracy will be impacted by ruling. AS THE U.S. SUPREME COURT prepares to consider a lawsuit in which a federal appellate court ruled Wisconsin's legislativ...


Read More

'Questions about sewer proposal'

June 26, 2017 at 4:00 pm | In regards to the write up about the proposed waste water plant in South Beloit, could the following numbers please be released to the citizens of South Beloit? How many gallons of water does the pl...


Read More

'Contributions to make to world'

June 26, 2017 at 4:00 pm | In his letter to the Public Forum of June 14, Mr. Don Hilbig bemoans these days as a time when women have "lost their way." He would, no doubt, prefer it if women stayed in the kitchen, cooked there...


Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2017 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy